Echo Station: Exploring Star Wars Beyond The Daily News




more popular brands at tfaw.com

 

Echo Station: Exploring Star Wars Beyond The Daily News




 



tpm_video0.gif (14819 bytes) DVD - Who needs it?
Review: various TPM video formats

by Toryn Farr
Published 5/21/00


Wondering if you need to get that Asian VCD import?

Video Formats -- A Primer

This is not by any means an exhaustive treatise on the subject -- I'm trying not to be too technical here.

Anamorphic: A means by which a wider image is squeezed to fit a smaller-width rectangle, most often a widescreen film stored on 35mm film (for instance, the film strip you got in your TPM Collector's Edition). A special oval lens is used on the projector to stretch the picture to its intended width on the theater screen.    

Anamorphic Widescreen: You'll often see this term on DVDs. This means the entire width of the picture is available, but it has been stored in compressed form. Anamorphic widescreen allows more image data to be stored in less space because the black bars at the top and bottom need not be included in the file.

Artifacts. A side effect of compression to reduce file size, artifacts are obvious blocks or graininess (pixellation) in video playback.

Aspect Ratio. Very simply the ratio between the width and the height of the displayed picture. For instance, a standard TV screen has a ratio of 4:3, also referred to as 1.33:1. "Pan and scan" or "full screen" videos are displayed at the same ratio as a TV -- 4:3. The new, wider HDTVs display at 16:9, or 1.78:1, also known as widescreen. Cinematic films are shot in a variety of aspect ratios, most commonly 1.66:1, 1.85:1 ("flat"), or 2.40:1 ("scope"). In order to fit these various ratios onto TV screens, the images must either be cropped, or else the full image is shown with black bars in the extra space (letterboxed).

DTV: Digital TV. A method whereby the image is stored and broadcast as digital data rather than analog signal. Includes both standard-definition (SD) and high-definition (HD) digital formats. The advantage: for the same amount of bandwidth, you can stuff a lot more information into a digital signal than an analog signal. 

DV: Digital Video. Video that is recorded and stored as digital information (0s and 1s). This is preferable to older, analog methods like tape because, with internal error-checking, the quality of information stored digitally will never degrade, and each copy is exactly like the master.

DVD: Digital Video Disc / Digital Versatile Disc. This is the name of both a physical disc and of a complex, high-quality standard for data. In general it can store and display 345,600 pixels (720x480) pixels of video for up to 2 hours (4 if double sided), plus Dolby Digital sound with up to 8 tracks.  I will let you go to the rec.video.dvd usenet's FAQ  if you want more technical info.

Full Screen: TV image that fills the screen. Not necessarily "pan and scan," this can also be "soft matte."

HDTV: High Definition Television. As hardware, this is an analog or digital television that has a 16:9 aspect ratio with about 5 times the resolution of standard TV. The notation H/DTV is often used to specifically refer to high-definition digital TV.

LD: Laserdisc. A video system on the wane in America but still popular in Asia, video is stored on large, analog discs holding approximately 272,160 (567x480) pixels. In potential its picture is not quite as good as DVD, although its Dolby Surround Sound is slightly better. The differences in quality are probably not enough to be perceived by most people. LD discs and players are now far more expensive than their DVD counterparts, but there are many movies available on LD that probably won't make it to DVD any time soon, if at all.

Letterbox: In order to display a picture that differs in aspect ratio from a TV screen, black bars are used to fill up the rest of the space. Most commonly you'll see black bars at the top and bottom of widescreen movies shown on standard TVs -- the black bars take anywhere from 25% to 33% of the screen.

MPEG: A compression standard for digital video and audio developed by the Moving Picture Experts Group. MPEG-1 what you see in Quicktime movies such as the Star Wars trailers downloaded on the web or on Video CDs. It's roughly equivalent in quality to VHS.   MPEG-2 is the current standard for high-quality digital video, both broadcast and DVD-based. There's currently an MPEG-4 in the works.

NTSC: A standard television format used in North America, 30 frames per second, 640 x 480 resolution at 60hz.

PAL:: Standard television format used in the rest of the galaxy (there's also SECOM or SECAM, which I believe is similar.) 25fps 768 x 576 resolution at 50hz.

Pan and Scan: In order to fit a widescreen movie onto a standard TV screen, the image must be cropped somehow. This is done by editors who choose which part of the picture to crop, panning a "window" 75% or less of the full width over the image. Sometimes they will also zoom in and out and move the "window" up or down, but for the most part this involves just lopping off one or both sides of the frame. You'll know you're missing something if you see this message: "This film has been modified from its original version. It has been formatted to fit your screen."

Soft Matte: The practice of shooting a film with a 1:33:1 aspect ratio and then masking the top and bottom for theatrical display. This allows the filmmaker to release a video for standard TV without losing any of the intended image and without the annoying "letterbox" black bars.

VCD: Video CD. A compact disc containing digital video most often with MPEG-1 compression that can be played on VCD players, some DVD players so equipped, and PC CD-ROM drives.

Widescreen: Image that is wider than the standard TV screen, usually 16:9 aspect ratio. Must be displayed on standard TV using letterboxing.

Every once in a while, I like to to feel I am not being ripped off by Lucas and his companies. This usually happens when I am asleep. During my waking hours, however, I am painfully aware of how my chain is being jerked, and I don't like it.

I'm thinking right now of an "exclusive" POTF action figure I want that cost probably 3 cents to make and is now selling in the secondary market for $10. But I digress. The topic of today's discussion is: How many different versions of the TPM video can you buy and still feel unsatisfied? The answer: A lot.

When a subset of the internet community of fans started whining about the lack of a DVD release for Episode I, I had no sympathy. First of all, I did not have a DVD player, had never seen a DVD, and just basically thought VHS was good enough. It's akin to the time in my life when I listened to my favorite music on cassette tape and had no interest in CD. I figured the common, non-audio-obsessed-snob type person would be able to perceive scant difference in the quality, and the price differential was so great, I thought you had to be a fool to spend that much for each title. Then one night I bought a CD player and a single CD, a James Galway compilation, as a gift for my soon-to-be-husband. I hooked it up, sat down in the middle of the room, and nearly cried when I realized I could hear every nuance, every breath, of that performance, with no crackling, no noise at all. The silence during rests was just that -- perfect silence. I have not bought a cassette tape since.

So now I've seen DVD. And I am a convert. Too bad there's not one available to review, so we'll have to settle for the various VHS and VCD versions out there.

VHS - Collector's Edition

Widescreen ImageI'm betting this is the version most True Fans have purchased, mostly because there was no other way to get the widescreen edition if you live in America. (I'm told the people in UK can get a widescreen without the frills for a reasonable price.) I bought mine from the official site, so it came with a free, exclusive poster -- I was expecting it to be a cheesy little poster about 8" x 10", but no, it was huge (27" x 40") and quite nice to look at. Once I find a frame, it will have a home here in my office. This version also comes with a little booklet containing excerpts from the Art of Episode I book, a strip of original film mounted in a cardboard frame, and a nifty box with a scene from Naboo on the inside. A few comments about the packaging:

  • I'm sure a lot of fans liked getting these extras, but I would have appreciated being able to get a widescreen version of the movie for a reasonable price without all the gewgaws.
  • The special behind the scenes documentary was good, but only ten minutes? I was hoping for a lot more.
  • I already have the Art of Episode I book, so the booklet was superfluous. However, it's definitely a great product. They've taken most of my favorite images and put them in here in reduced size. I ended up liking it despite my resentment at the whole idea of being forced to buy it.
  • The film strip is pretty worthless. There's no way to display it, and even if you could, it's in that "squished" format that requires an anamorphic lens to see properly.
  • The box, while pretty, is also a pain. It doesn't fit with the other videotapes, so it ended up with my books.

As for quality, I think the video is just about as good as you can get for a VHS tape. This really is a visually stunning movie. The colors are vivid, the whole look is clean and beautiful. However, you only get a certain number of lines of resolution from a VHS tape, and with nearly 1/3 of the screen going unused because of the letterbox format, the actual image from the movie uses even fewer lines of resolution. It's okay to watch from ten feet away on the sofa, as long as you don't want to be able to see small details or read the credits at the end -- there's just too much loss in the compression to be able to read the fine print.

VHS - Pan and Scan

Pan and Scan ImageI got this so my kid could watch the thing over and over without my worrying if it got worn out. Its major advantages are that it's cheaper than the Collector's Edition, and since the image fills the screen from top to bottom (they call it "full screen"), you're getting more lines of resolution, so the image is clearer than the widescreen. Of course, you're missing nearly half the picture to either side, as we all know. There are many, many scenes where this is bothersome, especially at the end during the last duel when you can't see all the action, and during the discussion between Obi-Wan and Yoda when you can see only one of them at a time. I have a lot of movies in pan and scan, and I don't think any of them suffer quite as much as the Star Wars films from the pan-and-scan editing. There's just too much going on in each frame of a Star Wars film for any of it to be cut.

VCD - Asian Import

VCD CoverI bought this so I could play it in my PC's CD-ROM drive and get some screen captures. After a few false starts (this is NOT intuitive) I got it to play on my CD-ROM using Windows MediaPlayer and finally got the screen capture to work, though not as well as I'd like. This is a legitimate Fox/Lucasfilm product, apparently sold only for the Malaysian market. I was a little alarmed when a screen popped up saying this VCD was not supposed to be sold outside the territories of Malaysia, but what the heck ... it's mine now!

The packaging is beautiful, making this a nice collectible to own. The two disks come in jewel cases with two different covers, wrapped in a cardstock cover that looks very much like the VHS covers. The inside of this cover is a wide shot of Theed, the same as the inside of the Collector's Edition box. My only complaint is that this cover folds out flat, so it's useless as a slipcase. The disks themselves are gorgeous, with full color screen prints of the same art as the cover. This is a high-quality print job with, as far as I can tell, no typos or other errors you usually get from bootleg copies.

I've scanned the covers and disks so you can see what I'm talking about:

Artifacts
A side-effect of MPEG-1 compression, the artifacts around fast-moving objects are quite apparent, especially on a big TV.

Besides playing it on my CD-ROM drive, I also tested this version on my laptop's DVD-ROM player and a friend's DVD player with a 31" television screen. It holds its own fairly well in comparison with the VHS tapes as far as video quality, but during fast action the compression becomes apparent as the image breaks up into blocks, a problem called artifacting. You can really see this around the lightsabers during a fight. Overall, I'd rather watch the VHS version. The only advantage the VCD has is that it will not wear out like a tape will.

This VCD comes in PAL format and there are no subtitles. (I believe www.yesasia.com is supposed to have the NTSC version if your DVD player can't handle PAL -- and some can't -- but their version has Chinese subtitles.) The sound quality seems at least equivalent to my VHS copies. Unfortunately, it is only a pan-and-scan version -- something the seller did not warn me about. Apparently there is not a widescreen edition of TPM on VCD -- at least not that I have found. Y'all let me know if you find one.

That being said, I do think this one was worth the price I paid: $13.88 plus shipping from www.coolvcd.com. And since I bought two (one for a friend) I got a shipping upgrade to FedEx for free. Shop around for the best deal -- other places that I know of where you can get this version are www.video-cds.com, www.videocds.com, www.videovalley.com, www.vcdgallery.com and www.getvcds.com.

Laserdisc - Japanese Import

I don't know anybody with a laserdisc player, although I have read that the Japanese laserdisc version of TPM is pretty much equivalent to DVD in quality of picture and sound. Unfortunately it costs $100 if you can find it at all, which means buying it is just one more way for us fans to get reamed.

lil_jar_jar.gif (6521 bytes)
(Toryn Farr knew everything about Star Wars back in 1977 thanks to Starlog Magazine. She's been trying to keep her know-it-all reputation ever since. During the 90 minutes per day her preschooler is napping, Toryn attempts to run an internet design business and write fantasy fiction.)

No results were found using your keywords.

Return to Index