|
|
|
||||
Every once in a while, I like to to feel I am not being ripped off by Lucas and his companies. This usually happens when I am asleep. During my waking hours, however, I am painfully aware of how my chain is being jerked, and I don't like it. I'm thinking right now of an "exclusive" POTF action figure I want that cost probably 3 cents to make and is now selling in the secondary market for $10. But I digress. The topic of today's discussion is: How many different versions of the TPM video can you buy and still feel unsatisfied? The answer: A lot. When a subset of the internet community of fans started whining about the lack of a DVD release for Episode I, I had no sympathy. First of all, I did not have a DVD player, had never seen a DVD, and just basically thought VHS was good enough. It's akin to the time in my life when I listened to my favorite music on cassette tape and had no interest in CD. I figured the common, non-audio-obsessed-snob type person would be able to perceive scant difference in the quality, and the price differential was so great, I thought you had to be a fool to spend that much for each title. Then one night I bought a CD player and a single CD, a James Galway compilation, as a gift for my soon-to-be-husband. I hooked it up, sat down in the middle of the room, and nearly cried when I realized I could hear every nuance, every breath, of that performance, with no crackling, no noise at all. The silence during rests was just that -- perfect silence. I have not bought a cassette tape since. So now I've seen DVD. And I am a convert. Too bad there's not one available to review, so we'll have to settle for the various VHS and VCD versions out there. VHS - Collector's Edition
As for quality, I think the video is just about as good as you can get for a VHS tape. This really is a visually stunning movie. The colors are vivid, the whole look is clean and beautiful. However, you only get a certain number of lines of resolution from a VHS tape, and with nearly 1/3 of the screen going unused because of the letterbox format, the actual image from the movie uses even fewer lines of resolution. It's okay to watch from ten feet away on the sofa, as long as you don't want to be able to see small details or read the credits at the end -- there's just too much loss in the compression to be able to read the fine print. VHS - Pan and Scan
VCD - Asian Import
The packaging is beautiful, making this a nice collectible to own. The two disks come in jewel cases with two different covers, wrapped in a cardstock cover that looks very much like the VHS covers. The inside of this cover is a wide shot of Theed, the same as the inside of the Collector's Edition box. My only complaint is that this cover folds out flat, so it's useless as a slipcase. The disks themselves are gorgeous, with full color screen prints of the same art as the cover. This is a high-quality print job with, as far as I can tell, no typos or other errors you usually get from bootleg copies. I've scanned the covers and disks so you can see what I'm talking about:
Besides playing it on my CD-ROM drive, I also tested this version on my laptop's DVD-ROM player and a friend's DVD player with a 31" television screen. It holds its own fairly well in comparison with the VHS tapes as far as video quality, but during fast action the compression becomes apparent as the image breaks up into blocks, a problem called artifacting. You can really see this around the lightsabers during a fight. Overall, I'd rather watch the VHS version. The only advantage the VCD has is that it will not wear out like a tape will. This VCD comes in PAL format and there are no subtitles. (I believe www.yesasia.com is supposed to have the NTSC version if your DVD player can't handle PAL -- and some can't -- but their version has Chinese subtitles.) The sound quality seems at least equivalent to my VHS copies. Unfortunately, it is only a pan-and-scan version -- something the seller did not warn me about. Apparently there is not a widescreen edition of TPM on VCD -- at least not that I have found. Y'all let me know if you find one. That being said, I do think this one was worth the price I paid: $13.88 plus shipping from www.coolvcd.com. And since I bought two (one for a friend) I got a shipping upgrade to FedEx for free. Shop around for the best deal -- other places that I know of where you can get this version are www.video-cds.com, www.videocds.com, www.videovalley.com, www.vcdgallery.com and www.getvcds.com. Laserdisc - Japanese Import I don't know anybody with a laserdisc player, although I have read that the Japanese laserdisc version of TPM is pretty much equivalent to DVD in quality of picture and sound. Unfortunately it costs $100 if you can find it at all, which means buying it is just one more way for us fans to get reamed.
|