Echo Station: Exploring Star Wars Beyond The Daily News




more popular brands at tfaw.com

 

Echo Station: Exploring Star Wars Beyond The Daily News




 

Review by Toryn Farr
Page Two

THE ADVENTURE CONTINUES by Paul Davids and Hollace Davids ** 

#1 The Glove of Darth Vader
#2 The Lost City of the Jedi
#3 Zorba the Hutt's Revenge
#4 Mission from Mount Yoda
#5 Queen of the Empire
#6 Prophets of the Dark Side

This series has a dismal reputation among Star Wars fans, and deservedly so. It has logic and plot holes you could drive a landspeeder through, and there seems to have been no effort made on continuity. For instance, when Artoo and Threepio visit Kessel in the first book, it has forests and an outdoor stadium -- in contradiction to later descriptions of Kessel as having almost no atmosphere. The writing itself isn't terrible; the series is aimed at 9-12 year olds, but I think most kids would find the vocabulary pleasantly challenging. There are worse things your children could be reading.

The series does have a couple of things going for it. One, it gives the truly desperate fan a needed dose of adventure with our favorite heroes -- Luke, Leia, Han, Chewie, and the droids. Two, it's a treasure trove for trivia buffs. Another plus is the inclusion of dozens of illustrations in each volume, and the cover art on the reprints ain't half bad, either.

Overall, these books will probably only appeal kids and to hardcore Star Wars fans with a certain tolerance for ambiguity -- such as myself!


JUNIOR NOVELIZATIONS  

A New Hope adapted by Larry Weinberg
The Empire Strikes Back adapted by Larry Weinberg
Return of the Jedi adapted by Elizabeth Levy
Written in a "see spot run" style, these are just too simplistic even for young readers. The interior full-color photo section is poorly reproduced. Don't waste your money.

Shadows of the Empire by Christopher Golden ****
In contrast to the other novelizations, this one is refreshingly well written and worthy of a young Star Wars fan. It follows the original novel so faithfully I wonder why anyone would read the longer version.


Star Wars (chunky book) **
The Empire Strikes Back (chunky book)
Return of the Jedi (chunky book)
These well-written pocket-sized chunky books adapted by John Whitman for 9-12 year olds tell the story of the movies with ugly two-color illustrations on practically every panel.


ADVENTURE JOURNALS ***

Captive to Evil (Princess Leia's Journal)
Hero for Hire (Han Solo's Journal)
The Fight for Justice (Luke Skywalker's Journal)
Fairly well written, these slender journals tell the story of A New Hope from the first-person POV of each character. I especially like Han's Journal because it captures his irreverent voice very well.










GOLDEN BOOKS  

Adventure in Beggar's Canyon (Little Golden Book) ***
I can't say a lot for the artwork, but the story's kind of cool. Luke and his friend Windy crash their T-16 and must face Jawas, Tusken Raiders, and a Krayt Dragon before being rescued by Ben Kenobi and riding home with him on a dewback. At least they got Windy's sex right (see last entry below).

Meltdown on Hoth (Little Golden Book) *
Very silly tale behind Threepio's line: "How we're going to dry out all her clothes, I really don't know," from ESB. I just couldn't warm up to this one.

A More Wretched Hive: The Mos Eisley Cantina (scratch-n-sniff) (This book no longer available from publisher) *
Did you know Greedo smells like rotten eggs? But Jabba has a nice, woody scent! This is the silliest excuse for a Star Wars book I've ever seen. I suppose kids might like it for the gross-out factor . . . for about five minutes.

A New Hope (with tattoos****
The Empire Strikes Back (with tattoos)
Return of the Jedi (with tattoos)
These books each come with 20 cool rub-on tattoos and are loaded with photos from the movies. Fun for you and your kid! Buy two of each!

Journey to Mos Eisley  **
The Hoth Adventure
Escape from Jabba's Palace
These three volumes are full of photos from the movies tracing the stories indicated by the titles, but unlike the books listed above they are printed on uncoated paper, so the photos look like crap.

The Greatest Battles (Screamin' 3-D)  *
The 3-D glasses inside let you see the bad artwork in multiple dimensions. 

Pilots and Spacecraft (glow in the dark) **
I'm not sure the Escape Pod would have been on my top ten list of spacecraft to be reproduced here, but the glow-in-the-dark Boba Fett is worth the price of the book. 

Princess Leia's Escape from the Death Star (Spelling Workbook) ****
Luke Skywalker's Battle with Darth Vader (Reading Workbook)
Han Solo's Rescue from Jabba the Hutt (Math Workbook) - ISBN 0-307 21306-4
These workbooks for grades 2-6 are full color throughout and are jammed with lots of fun activities and puzzles to work on reading and spelling and comprehension. If only they'd been around in the 1960's!

Chewbacca the Wookiee (Super Shape Book) *
Han Solo: Rebel Hero (Super Shape Book)
Luke Skywalker: Jedi Knight (Super Shape Book)
R2-D2 & C-3PO: Droid Duo (Super Shape Book)
Princess Leia: Rebel Leader (Super Shape Book)
Pathetic illustrations and stories that simply rehash scenes from the movies almost word-for-word -- yawn. Even my two-year-old grew tired of these quickly and cried for the ones with real photos. 


Keep Reading!  There's more!

Return to Index